One of the country’s foremost Title Insurance companies was brought into a lawsuit by the plaintiffs who alleged that they had been defrauded into selling their house. The Title Insurance company retained ALBPC to defend their interests and Pete Reid was assigned to the case.
The plaintiffs filed a Complaint and claimed that it was sufficiently detailed to avoid the need for any further discovery. Pete Reid prepared a motion to compel discovery in Supreme Court and the Judge ordered the plaintiffs to respond, commending Pete Reid on the quality of the papers and arguments.
The plaintiffs then provided discovery responses which simply objected to every question posed. Immediately, Pete Reid prepared another motion and the Judge again agreed that the plaintiffs had acted inappropriately, ordering them to respond properly. Following the discovery motions the plaintiffs for the first time indicated that they might settle the case if they received upwards of a six figure settlement. ALBPC made a four figure offer on behalf of the Title Insurance company.
Pete Reid then conducted a full review of the thousands of documents received relating to the various mortgages, closings, and title insurance claims and concluded that the allegations of fraud could be defeated.
ALBPC led the depositions of the plaintiffs and confronted each plaintiff with documentary evidence that suggested glaring inaccuracies in their testimony. Upon completion of the plaintiffs’ depositions the defense case was considerably stronger and ALBPC withdrew their offer to settle the case. It is a commonly held myth at many law firms that one cannot win a case at a deposition, one can only lose it. The work done by Pete Reid and Colin Kaufman on this case, disproved that myth.
A few weeks after the depositions, the plaintiffs agreed to settle the case with the other Defendants for a vastly reduced total. The settlement amount was entirely funded by other Defendants and the Title Insurance company was once again delighted with the work of Pete Reid and ALBPC
Colin Kaufman and Pete Reid represented the Title Insurance company in this action in New York Supreme Court.